Showing posts with label frank thomas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label frank thomas. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 21, 2012

Frank Thomas - Disney's Nine Old Men

Frank Thomas (September 5, 1912 - September 8, 2004) attended Stanford University where he began his lifelong friendship with future "old man" Ollie Johnston. He also met two other students there who he'd end up working with at the Disney studio--animator James Algar and layout artist Thor Putnam.

Frank and Ollie, Standford campus 1932...


After graduation, Thomas went onto study at the Chouinard Art Institute in Los Angeles along with Putnam and then Johnston. Algar was the first to be hired at Disney, but the others followed not long after, Frank on September 24, 1934.

As was the norm, he started out as an in-betweener where he worked for six months. During this time, he was among a select group of beginners asked to attend the after-hours classes now being taught at the studio by Don Graham (who was promoted to full-time instructor the same day Thomas was hired). Walt was gearing up for Snow White and he wanted his animators ready for the task.

Frank became an assistant to Fred Moore, and his drawing skills excelled as he moved from simple clean-up to full animation work. He also picked up valuable tips and advice from the likes of Ham Luske, Les Clark and Wilfred Jackson. After about a year, Frank advanced to junior animator, and his pal Ollie took his place as assistant to Moore in March of 1936.



He'd been working at the studio for a year and a half, but Thomas still hadn't met Walt Disney. That changed with Frank's work on the Silly Symphony Little Hiawatha. The "boss" liked what he saw and soon after, the young animator was one of eight artists chosen to draw the seven dwarfs under the supervision of Fred Moore (and Vladimir Tytla).

In the scene where Snow White tells the dwarfs to wash up before dinner, Thomas noticed that the story sketches for the scene suggested that Dopey walked with a "hitch step" in order to keep pace with the others. So he added it. Frank said, "You were always looking for some way of making the character come to life, enriching him, making him a little different." Walt saw the addition in the pencil test and loved it, "Hey we oughta use that hitch step throughout the picture." All scenes of Dopey walking had to be redone. More than one angry animator would privately let Thomas know what they thought of his "brilliant" idea.



Two of the most powerful scenes in the movie have Frank's magic touch upon them. He animated the cottage sequence with the dwarfs grieving over the still body of Snow White...



...and also in the forest as they kneel on the ground around her bier. This last one in particular was a crucial moment in the film. No one in the studio knew for sure if the audience would feel for these "cartoon" characters. The animation had to "realistic, sincere, believable action."



In a 1973 interview with John Canemaker, Frank talked about the process of getting the right look for these scenes...
I made a lot of drawings. Are [the Dwarfs] better looking straight ahead? Are they better grouped together two or three looking around? And, of course, you always have help. Someone in story sketch, someone like Albert Hurter, or Don Da Gradi will make drawings. Don was great at getting the essence of the character. If it was sad, he'd make twelve drawings of a sad guy. You'll only use one in your scene, but you're ninety percent there. Frank Thomas, Nine Old Men p.178


When it came to the animation itself, Thomas wanted to keep the movement of the Dwarfs in check...
...not too much because this is sad and you want minimum movement; but in 'sincere' animation you find out if you do not move the character he goes flat and it kills it, and you can't make your point. In doing a sincere thing, in order to believe this guy is real, he's up there feeling this part, you have to keep him moving.
Frank Thomas, Nine Old Men p.178




Not all of Frank's animation made it into the final film...
A scene of Dopey collapsing in tears into Doc's shoulder was cut in half when a preview audience laughed; Dopey's face held an uncharacteristically pained expression which the audience misinterpreted. The final version begins as his face is nearly buried in Doc's shoulder and continues through his shoulder-heaving sobs.
John Canemaker, Nine Old Men, p.179



Possibly the most touching moment in the film is when we see Grumpy break down and bury his head in his hand. "The only Dwarf with a major body move," said Thomas.



Frank Thomas went on to animate dozens of Disney films and became one of the great animators of the Golden Age. He retired from the studio on January 31, 1978.

Research on Bambi...

Frank Thomas photos and sketches via John Canemaker's Walt Disney's Nine Old Men and the Art of Animation, 2001.
Snow White image scans copyright Disney.

Further reading:

    Tuesday, January 31, 2012

    The Nine Old Men

    1958 Photo: left to right, Kimball, Larson, Thomas, Davis, Johnston, Clark, Kahl, Lounsbery, Reitherman

    Much has been written about the Nine Old Men and their larger-than-life animation achievements. These were not the first talented artists to work for the Disney Studio, yet they certainly became it's creative core for more than 40 years.

    Probably the most definitive work on these 'conquistadors' of the Golden Age is John Canemaker's book, Walt Disney's Nine Old Men and the Art of Animation (Disney Editions, 2001, ISBN-10: 0786864966).

    Front Cover

    Canemaker recounts how Walt jokingly nicknamed this dream team after President Roosevelt's description of his contentious 1937 Supreme Court, "nine old men, all too aged to recognize a new idea."

    Newspaper Cartoon, February 9, 1937, Brooklyn Citizen via New Deal Network.

    Of course, the animators were neither old nor afraid of new ideas. Quite the opposite, they would be the leaders, taking the art of animation to new heights.

    The Nine Old Men were:

    1972 Photo: left to right, Kahl, Reitherman, Davis, Clark, Thomas, Kimball, Larson, Lounsbery, Johnston

    Animator Les Clark was the first to be hired in early 1927. The rest of the group came in between 1933-35, just as things were heating up for the making of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. From 1935-37, all nine of the very young "old men" would be involved.

    Throughout this month, we'll take a closer look at what each contributed to the film and in what capacity they served the animation factory that was the Disney Studio of the late 1930s.

    Further reading:

    Tuesday, December 27, 2011

    "An Art in Its Making" - The Book

    Front Cover and Spine

    Stephen Ison's animation art collection is beautifully reproduced in the 1994 Walt Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs: An Art in Its Making. The 192-page hardcover features loads of stunning full-color images of the artwork along with an introduction written by Steve and text by Martin Krause and Linda Witkowski.


    Synopsis by Gordon Flagg of Booklist magazine...
    Krause provides a critically incisive account of making the film, from its inception through its three years in production to its wildly enthusiastic reception by audiences and critics. Witkowski supplies a detailed, fairly technical explanation of the animation process as well as a guide to the preservation and handling of animation art designed to appeal to serious students of the genre. The heart of the volume is a retelling of the famous story scene-by-scene by means of cel reproductions, pencil drawings, and other production art.

    _______________________


    From an email correspondence with Steve earlier this year...

    Filmic Light: How did the Snow White...An Art in Its Making book come about?
    Stephen Ison: It started out to only be a catalogue for the exhibition. I kept pounding on the museum “powers that be” that it needed to be a book. I won...especially after Hyperion Press wanted to publish it.

    FL: Did you know authors Martin Krause or Linda Witkowski before the book?
    SI: Yes. Linda Witkowski was the person I had known who helped/taught me about conservation and preservation of animation art. She had actually done her college Masters thesis on cel restoration and conservation. Linda introduced me to Marty who helped me convince the IMA that an exhibition of art from Snow White could be successful.

    FL: How much were you involved with it?
    SI: Pretty much, every aspect, whether they always welcomed it or not.

    ________________________


    The opening of the 1994 Indianapolis Museum of Art exhibit featuring Steve's collection was quite an event. Diane Disney Miller attended along with animator greats Ward Kimball (along with his wife Betty), Marc Davis, Joe Grant, Ken O'Connor, Maurice Noble, and Bill Justice. What an opportunity it was for the attendees to meet and chat with these legends...and to get autographs.

    The title page from the book below comes from the Phil Sears Collection. It features the signatures of all of the animators mentioned above. In addition, it's signed by Frank Thomas and Ollie Johnston who could not attend the Indianapolis event due to an illness that Ollie’s wife was suffering from.

    Signed Title Page. Book sold for $499 (USD) on August 30, 2010. Image via Phil Sears Collectibles.
    [CLICK IMAGES FOR A BETTER VIEW]

    _______________________


    Steve's collection encompassed a wide range of animation art including "master backgrounds, concept art, cels, drawings, studio notes, character models, and various other items associated with the film." Here's a just a few of the dynamic images found within this handsome book.

    Layouts and storyboard drawings...




    Backgrounds and watercolors...




    Cel set-ups...



    Images copyright Disney/Hyperion Press/Stephen Ison

    _______________________


    In 1995, a "Disney Miniature Edition" was published. Same book, same number of pages, just smaller in size.

    Front Cover, miniature edition

    While both the original and miniature versions are no longer found via new bookstore channels, they are available from online resellers, often for a decent price. On a side note, it was about a decade ago that I stumbled upon a stack of 15 to 20 brand new shrink-wrapped copies of the full-size original, all dramatically reduced in price at a Barnes and Noble. I couldn't resist...I bought them all.

    Original Edition:
    Hardcover, 192 pages
    Published by Hyperion Press (September 23, 1994)
    ISBN-10: 0786861444
    ISBN-13: 978-0786861446
    Measures 10.9" x 9.6"

    Miniature Edition:
    Hardcover, 192 pages
    Published by Hyperion Press (November 3, 1995)
    ISBN-10: 0786861878
    ISBN-13: 978-0786861873
    Measures 5.5" x 4.7"

    Friday, November 18, 2011

    Starlog Magazine (50th Annivesary - 1987)

    In the September 1987 edition of Starlog Magazine (issue #122), a six page article paid tribute to the Golden Anniversary of Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. Short of Walt Disney himself, who better to relive the memories than two of the greats who helped create the film? It's a terrific interview with Frank Thomas and Ollie Johnston about the making of the movie and what it was like to be an animator back then.


    Cover image courtesy of Weimar World Service.


    [CLICK PAGES TO READ]

    Text images via John Pannozzi.

    Friday, September 9, 2011

    Everybody Loves Gustaf...or do they?

    Of all the drawings, sketches and artwork to spring from the production of Walt Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, there's probably none more recognizable as those pieces created by Gustaf Tenggren. Right smack in the heart of the Golden Age, Gustaf was there, one of the chosen few to be employed at the top animation studio of the day. Yet, his time at Disney wasn't necessarily all fairytales and happy endings.

    Tenggren was born November 3, 1896 in Magda, Sweden. When his father moved to the United States to find work, Gustaf was left in the care of his grandfather, Teng Tenggren, a painter and woodcarver. The arts were encouraged and in 1913, at the age of seventeen, Gustaf won a scholarship to the Valand School of Fine Arts.


    Children's Books... 

    By 1918, he had married (his first wife, Anna Peterson) and was being paid to create illustrations for a Swedish folklore and fairy tales compilation called Bland Tomtar och Troll (Among Gnomes and Trolls). Over the next decade, he would continue to contribute artwork to this annual, even though in 1920, he (and Anna) would immigrate to America to pursue his career as a illustrator.

    Lars Emanuelsson, Tenggren biographer and creator of gustaftenggren.com, shared (via Didier Ghez's excellent Disney History site) this illustration produced by Gustaf for the 1924 Bland Tomtar och Troll.

    Dark Forest Scene. Bland Tomtar och Troll, 1924.

    As Emanuelsson points out in regards to the similarities of the above image to that of the later Snow White Dark Forest scene, "I think it's pretty obvious where the inspiration came from."

    Dark Forest Scene. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, 1937.


    Tenggren settled first in Cleveland where he lived for a couple years. This photo below (also from Lars Emanuelsson via Didier Ghez's Disney History) shows Gustaf around age 25 playing chess with an unidentified man.

    Photo of Tenggren (left) in Cleveland, circa 1920-22.


    Gustaf relocated to New York City where things really started to take off career-wise. He found work as a successful illustrator of children's books as well as in some commercial advertisement jobs for magazines.

    Book Plate from Sven the Wise and Svea the Kind, 1932. Image via BPIB.


    The early 1930s saw Tenggren re-married (to Mollie Froberg) and living a rural farm life in upstate New York. By 1935, however, they'd moved back to the city where Gustaf was about to accept what would be for many, the job of a lifetime.

    __________________________


    Disney Studio (1936-1939)...

    Tenggren was steeped in the German and Norwegian folk tales (and their illustrators) from the 1800s. His work also showed similarities to fellow Swedish painter and illustrator John Bauer (Gustaf's predecessor at the Bland Tomtar och Troll annual), and both were influenced by English book illustrator Arthur Rackham. It so happens that this was the style--this old European storybook feel--that Walt Disney was looking to infuse into his first feature.

    Gustaf accepted the position of an Art Director on Snow White and moved to California. He took his place as a Disney Studio inspirational and concept artist, alongside the likes of Albert Hurter, Ferdinand Horvath, and Joe Grant. These guys were the dream team. Their job was to create artwork that would inform the animators and layout artists on how the characters, scenes and/or backgrounds should look.

    As Lars Emanuelsson states on his website, Tenggren's drawings and paintings...
    ...had a major influence on some central scenes, such as the interiors of the dwarfs’ cottage, the queen’s laboratory, and the scenes in the woods where Snow White flees from the hunter.

    Gustaf's Snow White artwork made such an impression that it was--and still is--used time and again in countless promotional items, posters, book illustrations and merchandise. The cast portrait, the Witch at her cauldron, Snow White and Prince on horseback--see all these and more in the one sheet and 40x60 movie posters, the British F.O.H. cards and North American lobby cards, the Valentine and Sons postcards, Cynthia Rylant's 2009 book, the vintage Roma tea tin and even the Disneyland dark ride.




    More images from his elegant and distinctive concept art portfolio...

    Prince Arrives. Image via John Canemaker's 1996 Before the Animation Begins, p. 44.

    At Wishing Well. Original artwork. Image from collector Pete Merolo via Disney History.

    Dark Forest. Image via John Canemaker's 1996 Before the Animation Begins, p. 44.

    Forest Rough Layout. Image via Snow White...An Art in Its Making, 1994, p. 77.

    Dwarfs March Home. Original Mixed Media on Board. Image via Heritage Auctions.

    Dwarfs Arrive Home. Original Ink and Watercolor. Image via Heritage Auctions.

    Dwarfs on Stairs. Faux-woodcut line drawing. Image via John Canemaker's 1996 Before the Animation Begins, p. 38.

    Queen and Magic Mirror. Original Ink and Watercolor. Image via Heritage Auctions.

    Poison Apple. Image via Cynthia Rylant's 2009 Snow White..., p. 24.

    Happy Ending. Image via Cynthia Rylant's 2009 Snow White..., p. 29.

    It is sometimes mistakenly thought that Gustaf did not receive any screen credit for his contributions to Snow White. Yet, he is indeed listed as one of the Art Directors at the start of the film. Both Albert Hurter and Joe Grant were mentioned as Character Designers. It was Ferdinand Horvath that, sadly, was left off the list.

    _______


    In between feature projects, Tenggren contributed to the Silly Symphonies, specifically Hiawatha, The Ugly Duckling, and the Academy Award-winning The Old Mill.

    Concept Art Painting for The Old Mill.

    _______


    Gustaf's greatest influence upon the Disney canon is in Pinocchio where his mark is seen throughout the film, in the design of the buildings and streets, the sign posts and lamps, and in the characters themselves.

    Village Street Inspirational Sketch. Image via Disneywiki.

    Blue Fairy Inspirational Sketch. Image via Disneywiki.


    Tenggren Concept Art. Video posted by AdamLore.

    _______


    His last Disney project was Bambi. Tenggren would head out to Yosemite National Park where he'd set up his easel and paint some most spectacular renderings of the forest...too spectacular as it turns out. Years later, Frank Thomas was quoted as saying...
    He did some amazing pictures. They were different than anything anyone else was doing. And they were impossible to use.
    Before the Animation Begins, Canemaker, p41.
    The paintings were so detailed that they took three days each to create. The movie would have taken forever to complete. So Walt moved the look of the film in a different direction.

    Bambi Forest Scene. Attributed most likely to Tenggren. Image via Michael Sporn's Splog.

    Tenggren working on Bambi, circa 1938.


    Much has been said about the conflicts and controversies surrounding Gustaf Tenggren and his relatively short tenure at the Disney Studio. He was not liked by many of his animator colleagues. They complained of his aloofness and apparent arrogance. Yet, others said he was cooperative, just not sociable. This need by Gustaf to be left alone is not so reprehensible, but then there was the drink.

    He had an real alcohol problem which at times may have resulted in muddled thinking and behavior. He was also known to be a philanderer from which a bit of a scandal developed. Animator Milt Kahl about blew a fuse when he learned that his underage niece (working a summer job at the studio) had gone camping alone with Tenggren on one of his Bambi excursions to Yosemite.

    It may have been this last incident, or a combinations of factors, but something motivated Gustaf Tenggren to leave his employment with Disney in January of 1939. There must have been hard feelings within the studio ranks. A year later, when Pinocchio was finally released, Tenggren's name was nowhere to be found on the picture that he'd contributed so much to.

    __________________________


    The Tenggren Books and Golden Books...

    Gustaf was not idle in his post-Disney years. Just the opposite. He began to develop his own trademark line called The Tenggren Books. The first in the series was The Tenggren Mother Goose, published in 1940.















    He also struck up his long-running relationship with Golden Books. For the next 20 years, he would illustrate a whopping 25 titles. This included the most printed of all, The Poky Little Puppy, first published in 1942.













    Gustaf had one last encounter with his Disney (and even Snow White) past when in 1956 he illustrated the cover of The Saturday Evening Post. The My Dad Walt Disney piece attributed to Diane Disney Miller appeared in the November 17th issue.

    Saturday Evening Post, 1956. Image via Before the Animation Begins, p. 48.


    Gustaf and Mollie moved to Maine where he continued to work on his artwork almost until his death from lung cancer in April of 1970. His collection of paintings and illustrations were later donated by his wife to the University of Minnesota.

    The conflict of egos experienced between Gustaf and his colleagues was not an isolated incident at the Disney Studio. Stories of controversy between other artists exist as well. It was a time of tremendous advancement in the world of animation. It was also the Great Depression. The stress of keeping the studio financially afloat was a real concern. The pressure to produce was intense. Yet through it all, illustrious were the results. No matter how the other animators--even the staunchest of adversaries--may have felt about him personally, they couldn't deny their admiration for Gustaf Tenggren's artistic contributions to the Golden Age.

    __________________________


    Further Tenggren reading from: